Raisin
Top Contributor
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2016
- Messages
- 1,471
- Reaction score
- 1,712
Bright. Netflix Original with Will Smith. Watchable but not anything special.
I know, plus I am sure the allies would have had more fighter planes than just Tom Hardy gliding over the beach. I will stand corrected but I recall studying it at school and there was battles of land, air and sea, not just one plane.Dunkirk, fuck me.
A huge military failure dressed up as a success.
Then the films a huge fucking failure as entertainment that they dressed up as a success.
One war vet said “ it really captured the atmosphere of dunkirk “
I reckon being stood on the beach waiting for an evac from a civilian fishing vessel having been ran out of France by an advancing nazi army, all the while being bombed by the luftwaffe was probably more fun tbf.
I know, plus I am sure the allies would have had more fighter planes than just Tom Hardy gliding over the beach. I will stand corrected but I recall studying it at school and there was battles of land, air and sea, not just one plane.
Disappointing really as Dunkirk seems to follow suit with Pearl Harbour in that regard.
Could have been so much more, definitely not of Hacksaw Ridge or Saving Private Ryan quality imo.
I'd go as far to say it was/is one of my favourite films in more recent times.if hacksaw wasn't Mel Gibson it would have done miles better at Oscars too.... shame as the story is unbelievable but true
Dunkirk, fuck me.
A huge military failure dressed up as a success.
Then the films a huge fucking failure as entertainment that they dressed up as a success.
One war vet said “ it really captured the atmosphere of dunkirk “
I reckon being stood on the beach waiting for an evac from a civilian fishing vessel having been ran out of France by an advancing nazi army, all the while being bombed by the luftwaffe was probably more fun tbf.
I know, plus I am sure the allies would have had more fighter planes than just Tom Hardy gliding over the beach. I will stand corrected but I recall studying it at school and there was battles of land, air and sea, not just one plane.
Disappointing really as Dunkirk seems to follow suit with Pearl Harbour in that regard.
Could have been so much more, definitely not of Hacksaw Ridge or Saving Private Ryan quality imo.
Don't get me wrong I was entertained.Apparently the allies DID have a lot of planes involved but they were further out in the channel fighting the Luftwaffe.
However the troops on the beaches didn’t get to see this and was a big issue amongst them that they thought the RAF hadn’t protected them. Hence at the end of the film someone said to the pilot “where were you”
Just an aspect the film portrayed.
That’s the thing with films
You can portray as much or as little as you want can’t you.
Going back to Doink’s point about being Dunkirk being a failure
I watched Das Boot again the other week
Thoroughly entertaining film set on a German U-Boat
40,000 went out in U-boats and 30,000 never came back (in b4 they all sailed to South America with Hitler) so you’d call that a failure wouldn’t you - only 25% chance of surviving
But was I entertained? Yes
Also Eddie the Eagle film
Kept coming last didn’t he
Bloody good film though
Critics ripped that to shreds, quite enjoyed it myself and apparently so did most of the audience. 7/10.Bright. Netflix Original with Will Smith. Watchable but not anything special.